When Robert Francis Prevost, a 69-year-old American, was chosen as the new Pope, the world had mixed reactions. Taking on the name Leo XIV, he became the first Pope Leo in over a century.
While Catholics globally celebrated, some MAGA supporters were less enthusiastic and voiced their objections on social media.
The white smoke that billowed above the Sistine Chapel signaled the conclusion of the cardinal’s conclave in Vatican City, drawing cheers from thousands gathered at St. Peter’s Square as Prevost appeared on the balcony.
His choice of the name Leo XIV followed 13 predecessors, each name symbolizing a “spirit, direction, and vision,” according to Dennis Doyle, a theologian and professor emeritus at the University of Dayton.
Pope Leo the Great, who served from 440 to 461 and famously negotiated with Attila the Hun to spare Rome, inspired the adoption of the name Leo.
Candida Moss, a CBS contributor, speculates that the new Pope’s choice of name may indicate an intention to engage with global repressive forces intellectually and reformatively.
Prevost’s past remarks support his progressive stance; he openly supports immigrants and justice campaigns like those for George Floyd.
His critiques of American Vice President JD Vance have sparked dissension among his critics.
Some detractors have labeled Leo XIV as a “woke Marxcist Pope,” citing him as being “worse than Francis.” Alt-right figure Mike Cernovich expressed his regrets to Catholics, highlighting Leo’s globalist tendencies.
There have been heated discussions regarding his positions on social platforms, especially his perceived favor of open borders and potential advocacy for contentious issues such as abortion.
Trump’s supporters recalled earlier instances where Leo has criticized conservative figures like JD Vance and expressed desires for more inclusive policies.
Joe Mannarino, another Trump supporter, disparagingly labeled Leo XIV as a “liberal piece,” worse than his predecessor, Francis, adding concerns that this new leadership might propagate liberal values within the Church.
This sentiment was echoed by MAGA influencer Vince Langman, who pointed to past tweets from 2015 where Prevost criticized Trump’s stance on immigration, branding him “WOKE.”
Amidst this criticism, Cardinal Prevost’s selection was anticipated by some, including former Trump strategist Steve Bannon, who noted Cardinal Prevost on his shortlist, albeit labeling him progressive.
The conversations around Pope Leo XIV’s leadership reveal a fragmented perception and significant curiosity about his future policies and the direction in which he will steer the Catholic Church.
As discussions continue, it remains important to consider diverse viewpoints and recognize the broader impacts of these ideological debates.
What do you think about Pope Leo XIV?
We’d love to hear your thoughts! Discuss this story with friends and family today.
